Followup CRM Blog, News and Resources

Newforma vs Procore

Written by FollowupCRM | Sep 6, 2024 2:35:07 PM

Core Platform Capabilities

Newforma Project Center specializes in project information management, focusing primarily on AEC firms that require robust document organization and communication tools. The platform excels at centralizing project data and streamlining information flow between team members. Its strength lies in its ability to handle large volumes of technical documentation and correspondence typical in architectural and engineering projects.

Procore takes a broader approach to construction management, offering a comprehensive suite of tools that extend beyond basic project management. The platform addresses every aspect of construction operations, from initial bidding through project completion. Its versatility makes it particularly appealing to general contractors and construction companies managing multiple complex projects simultaneously.

Project Management Features and Workflow

The way these platforms handle project management reflects their different approaches to construction software. Newforma emphasizes information organization and retrieval, with powerful search capabilities that help teams quickly locate specific documents or communications within vast project archives. The platform maintains a structured approach to document management, ensuring version control and maintaining clear audit trails.

Procore focuses on providing real-time project visibility and collaboration tools. The platform includes advanced scheduling features with interactive Gantt charts, allowing teams to visualize project timelines and dependencies. Its workflow automation capabilities help standardize processes across different projects and teams.

Construction teams particularly appreciate Procore's field-friendly features, which include:

  • Real-time progress tracking and reporting
  • Mobile photo documentation with automatic organization
  • Digital punch lists with location tracking
  • Quality and safety inspection tools
  • RFI management with automated routing

Document Control and Information Management

Document management forms a critical component of both platforms, though each approaches it differently. Newforma excels in email integration and document organization, automatically capturing and organizing project-related emails and attachments. The platform's advanced search capabilities extend across all project documentation, making it easier to locate specific information quickly.

Procore's document management system focuses on accessibility and collaboration. The platform maintains a centralized repository for all project documentation, with version control and approval workflows that ensure teams always work with the most current information. Its cloud-based architecture allows for seamless sharing and real-time updates across project teams.

Mobile Capabilities and Field Operations

The increasing importance of mobile access in construction management has influenced how both platforms approach field operations. Procore has invested heavily in mobile functionality, creating a robust mobile app that provides nearly full platform functionality on mobile devices. Field teams can access drawings, submit RFIs, update punch lists, and document site conditions directly from their mobile devices.

Newforma's mobile offerings, while functional, prioritize information access over comprehensive field management tools. The mobile app allows users to view project information and documents, but some advanced features remain limited to the desktop version.

Financial Management and Cost Control

Financial management capabilities represent one of the most significant differentiators between these platforms. Procore provides comprehensive financial tools that integrate seamlessly with its project management features. Users can manage budgets, track costs, and process change orders within the same platform they use for project management.

The platform includes sophisticated forecasting tools that help teams anticipate and manage project costs more effectively. These financial capabilities extend to:

  1. Budget tracking with real-time cost updates and forecasting
  2. Automated payment application processing and approval workflows
  3. Change order management with impact analysis tools
  4. Comprehensive financial reporting with customizable dashboards
  5. Integration with major accounting systems for seamless data flow

Integration Ecosystem and Extensibility

The ability to integrate with other construction and business software has become increasingly important. Procore maintains an extensive integration marketplace with hundreds of pre-built connections to popular construction and business applications. This ecosystem allows organizations to create a seamless flow of information between different systems and departments.

Newforma focuses on integrations specifically relevant to AEC firms, particularly with design and engineering software. While its integration options may be more limited compared to Procore, they are well-tailored to the needs of architecture and engineering professionals.

User Experience and Adoption

The user experience differs significantly between these platforms. Procore emphasizes intuitive navigation and user-friendly interfaces, making it easier for new users to adapt to the system. The platform's design focuses on reducing the learning curve while maintaining powerful functionality.

Newforma's interface, while comprehensive, may require more time to master. However, once users become familiar with the system, its powerful organization and search capabilities can significantly improve productivity. The platform's design reflects its focus on technical users in architecture and engineering roles.

Implementation and Support Services

Both platforms recognize the importance of proper implementation and ongoing support for successful adoption. The key difference lies in their approach to implementation. While Procore emphasizes a phased rollout strategy with dedicated project managers, Newforma focuses on helping organizations establish proper document control and information management processes from the start.

Procore provides comprehensive onboarding programs, including:

  • Dedicated implementation specialists
  • Customized training programs
  • Regular check-ins during the implementation phase
  • Access to extensive online learning resources
  • 24/7 technical support

Newforma's support and implementation services include:

  • Email and phone-based technical support
  • Online knowledge base resources
  • Training documentation and guides
  • Project implementation assistance
  • Contract administration workflow automation

Industry-Specific Optimization

Understanding how each platform serves different segments of the construction industry helps organizations make more informed decisions. Newforma's strengths align particularly well with architecture and engineering firms that prioritize document management and information organization. The platform's capabilities in managing technical documentation and correspondence make it especially valuable for design-focused organizations.

Procore's broader approach serves the needs of general contractors and construction companies managing multiple projects across different sectors. Its comprehensive feature set addresses the full lifecycle of construction projects, from preconstruction through completion and handover.

Future Development and Innovation

Both platforms continue to evolve, incorporating new technologies and responding to industry needs. Procore regularly introduces new features and improvements based on user feedback and industry trends. The platform's development roadmap includes enhanced artificial intelligence capabilities and improved automation tools.

Newforma maintains its focus on improving core information management capabilities while gradually expanding its feature set to meet changing user needs. The platform's development priorities reflect its commitment to serving the specific requirements of AEC firms.

Data Security and Compliance Standards

Data security remains a top priority for construction software platforms, particularly as projects become more digitized. Procore implements enterprise-grade security measures, including advanced encryption for data both in transit and at rest. The platform maintains compliance with major international security standards and regularly undergoes third-party security audits to ensure data protection.

Newforma approaches security with a focus on protecting sensitive architectural and engineering data. The platform offers both cloud and on-premises deployment options, giving organizations flexibility in how they manage their data. Regular security updates and patches ensure the platform maintains robust protection against emerging threats.

Cost Analysis and Return on Investment

Understanding the financial implications of implementing either platform requires careful consideration of both direct and indirect costs. Procore's pricing model scales with construction volume, which can result in higher costs for larger organizations but often provides better value for companies managing multiple complex projects simultaneously.

Newforma's licensing model may prove more cost-effective for smaller firms, particularly those focused primarily on architecture and engineering work. The platform's pricing structure typically includes perpetual licenses with annual maintenance fees, allowing organizations to better predict their software expenses.

When evaluating return on investment, organizations should consider:

  1. Time saved through improved document management and communication
  2. Reduced errors from better version control and information access
  3. Increased project visibility leading to better decision-making
  4. Improved collaboration reducing delays and rework
  5. Enhanced reporting capabilities supporting better resource allocation

Training and Professional Development

Professional development plays a crucial role in maximizing the benefits of either platform. Procore offers a comprehensive certification program that helps users demonstrate their expertise and advance their careers. The platform provides structured learning paths for different roles and skill levels, supported by interactive tutorials and hands-on exercises.

Newforma focuses its training resources on helping users master the platform's powerful organization and search capabilities. The company provides regular webinars and training sessions, along with detailed documentation and best practice guides.

Vendor Stability and Market Position

The long-term viability of software vendors significantly impacts platform selection decisions. Both Newforma and Procore have established strong market positions, though in different segments of the construction software market. Procore has experienced rapid growth, particularly in the general contractor segment, and maintains a strong financial position with regular platform updates and expansions.

Newforma maintains a stable presence in the AEC software market, with a loyal customer base among architecture and engineering firms. The company's focused approach to serving these specific sectors has helped it maintain consistent growth while continuing to enhance its core capabilities.

Choosing the Right Construction Software

Selecting between Newforma and Procore requires careful evaluation of organizational needs, technical requirements, and long-term objectives. Organizations should consider their primary focus areas, whether in design and engineering or general construction management, as this often indicates which platform will provide better value. The decision impacts not only current operations but also shapes how teams will collaborate and manage projects in the future.

Each platform offers distinct advantages that appeal to different segments of the construction industry. Newforma excels in managing technical documentation and communication for design-focused organizations, while Procore provides comprehensive construction management capabilities suited for general contractors and larger construction firms. Understanding these strengths helps organizations align their software choice with their operational needs and growth plans.

The ideal choice depends on specific organizational requirements, team composition, and project types. Careful evaluation of features, pricing, and support options, combined with hands-on testing through trials or demos, enables organizations to make informed decisions that support their operational goals and enhance project delivery capabilities.

Sources: [1] https://support.procore.com/references/contact-support [2] https://www.procore.com/pricing [3] https://www.newforma.com/newforma-konekt/ [4] https://www.techrepublic.com/article/procore-review/ [5] https://www.softwaresuggest.com/newforma [6] https://projectcenter.help.newforma.com/learning/tip-and-tricks/customer_support/ [7] https://support.procore.com/getting-started-with-procore/navigate-procores-support-site [8] https://www.itqlick.com/compare/procore/newforma-project-center [9] https://www.itqlick.com/newforma-project-center/pricing