ProjectWise vs Procore

Overview of ProjectWise and Procore

ProjectWise, developed by Bentley Systems, is an integrated project delivery platform designed specifically for architecture, engineering, and construction (AEC) projects. It focuses on providing tools for document management, collaboration, and workflow automation across the entire project lifecycle.

Procore, on the other hand, is a cloud-based construction management platform that provides a wide range of functionalities, from project scheduling to financial management and quality control. It caters to various stakeholders in the construction industry, including general contractors, specialty contractors, and owners.

Both platforms offer robust project management capabilities, but with different focuses. While ProjectWise excels in engineering document management and BIM collaboration, Procore stands out for its user-friendly interface, comprehensive project management features, and strong collaboration tools for all stakeholders.

User Experience and Interface

The user experience and interface of construction management software play a crucial role in its adoption and effectiveness. ProjectWise and Procore have distinct approaches to their user interfaces, each catering to different user preferences and needs.

ProjectWise's interface is designed with a focus on engineering workflows and document control. Users report that while it may have a steeper learning curve, the platform offers powerful tools for managing complex infrastructure projects. The interface is highly customizable, allowing organizations to tailor the system to their specific workflows and processes. This flexibility can be particularly beneficial for large enterprises with unique requirements.

Procore is known for its user-friendly interface and mobile-first approach. The platform is designed to be intuitive, making it easier for field teams to adopt and use regularly. Its mobile app is particularly praised for its functionality and ease of use on construction sites. This focus on accessibility and ease of use can be a significant advantage for companies looking to improve field-to-office communication and streamline project management processes.

Both platforms offer demos or trials, which can be invaluable in assessing their fit for your organization. It's recommended to involve key stakeholders in the decision-making process and potentially run pilot projects to fully evaluate the impact of each system on your operations.

Pricing and Licensing Models

Understanding the pricing and licensing models of ProjectWise and Procore is crucial for organizations considering these platforms. The cost of implementation can significantly impact the decision-making process, especially for smaller companies or those with budget constraints.

ProjectWise's pricing is not publicly disclosed and is typically based on the scale and complexity of the projects being managed. Pricing factors may include:

• Number of users
• Project volume
• Required modules and features
• Implementation and training needs

Bentley Systems offers both perpetual licensing and subscription-based models for ProjectWise, with the latter becoming increasingly popular. This flexibility in licensing options can be beneficial for organizations with varying project needs and budgets.

Procore's pricing is based on the annual construction volume (ACV) of the company. Their pricing model includes:

• Unlimited users
• Unlimited data storage
• No hidden fees
• Annual contracts based on construction volume

While exact figures are not publicly available, Procore's pricing is generally considered to be more transparent and predictable than ProjectWise's. This can be advantageous for companies looking to budget their software expenses more accurately.

It's important to note that both platforms represent a significant investment, especially for smaller construction companies. Users have reported that the cost can be a barrier to entry, particularly for Procore. However, many also find that the benefits in terms of improved efficiency and project outcomes justify the expense.

Implementation and Support

The implementation process and ongoing support are critical factors in the success of any construction management software. Both ProjectWise and Procore offer implementation services and support, but their approaches differ.

ProjectWise offers:

• Dedicated implementation team
• Customized training programs
• 24/7 support for critical issues
• Regular system updates and enhancements

ProjectWise's implementation process can be complex and time-consuming, especially for large enterprises with multiple integrations. This complexity is often due to the high level of customization available in the platform.

Procore provides:

• Guided implementation process
• Online training resources and certification programs
• 24/7 customer support
• Regular product updates and new feature releases

Procore is often praised for its customer support and the availability of training resources, which can help speed up adoption across organizations. However, some users have reported issues with response times and the depth of support provided, particularly for more complex technical issues.

When considering either platform, it's essential to factor in the time and resources required for implementation and training. The ease of adoption can significantly impact the overall success and return on investment of the software.

Integration Capabilities

In today's interconnected digital landscape, the ability of construction management software to integrate with other tools and systems is crucial. Both ProjectWise and Procore offer integration capabilities, but their approaches and strengths differ.

ProjectWise offers strong integration capabilities with:

• CAD and BIM software (e.g., AutoCAD, Revit, MicroStation)
• Other Bentley Systems products
• Microsoft Office suite

While third-party integrations are possible with ProjectWise, they may require more effort and customization. This can be both an advantage and a limitation, depending on an organization's specific needs and existing software ecosystem.

Procore boasts a large ecosystem of integrations, including:

• Accounting software
• ERP systems
• CRM platforms
• Scheduling tools
• BIM software

Procore's App Marketplace offers a wide range of pre-built integrations, making it easier for organizations to connect their existing tools with the platform. This extensive integration ecosystem can be a significant advantage for companies looking to create a seamless workflow across various software solutions.

Mobile Accessibility and Field Use

In the construction industry, where work often takes place on-site and away from the office, mobile accessibility is a crucial feature for project management software. Both ProjectWise and Procore offer mobile solutions, but their approaches and effectiveness differ significantly in real-world applications.

ProjectWise Edge Mobile application provides access to project data for professionals when away from their desk by offering:

• Direct access to secure electronic records for decision-making
• Access to multiple project repositories
• Real-time access to current project information
• Basic document viewing capabilities
• Simple markup functionality for field use

However, ProjectWise mobile functionality has some limitations. Users report issues with login requirements, browser compatibility, and server connectivity. The app requires iOS 9.0 or later and has received mixed reviews regarding its reliability and functionality.

Procore's mobile application demonstrates a stronger focus on field operations with comprehensive features:

• Quick Capture technology for voice-enabled input
• Real-time document editing and markup capabilities
• Comprehensive field reporting with electronic signatures
• Bookmarking system for important project items
• Procore Conversations for team communication
• Photo and video documentation tools
• Time and material tracking
• Daily log management
• Punch list creation and management
• RFI handling
• Specification access

Procore's mobile platform is designed for intuitive field use, allowing teams to maintain productivity while away from the office. The app has received positive feedback from companies with multiple job sites, particularly noting its effectiveness in transitioning from paper-based systems to digital workflows.

Offline Capabilities

ProjectWise provides basic offline functionality designed for essential field operations when internet connectivity is unavailable. The platform enables users to download and cache documents before going offline, allowing basic document viewing and limited markup capabilities in disconnected environments. When network connectivity is restored, ProjectWise automatically synchronizes any changes made during offline sessions back to the central system.

Procore delivers a more comprehensive offline experience with extensive functionality for field operations without internet access. Users can access, edit, and create various project documents, including daily logs, punch lists, and observations, even when working offline. The platform's sophisticated offline mode supports multiple users working simultaneously without connectivity, automatically resolving any conflicts when synchronization occurs.

Data Security and Compliance Standards

Construction projects often involve sensitive information and must adhere to strict regulatory requirements. Both platforms implement robust security measures to protect project data and ensure compliance with industry standards.

ProjectWise maintains stringent security protocols with multiple layers of protection, including advanced encryption for data transmission and storage. The platform offers granular permission controls, allowing administrators to manage access rights precisely for different user groups and project phases.

Procore emphasizes data protection through regular security audits, multi-factor authentication, and comprehensive backup systems. The platform maintains compliance with various international security standards and provides detailed audit trails for all user activities.

Performance and Scalability Options

The ability to handle growing project volumes and increasing user demands is essential for construction management software. Both platforms approach scalability differently, each with its own advantages for different organizational sizes.

ProjectWise demonstrates robust performance in handling large-scale projects with complex documentation requirements. The platform maintains consistent performance even when managing extensive BIM models and engineering documents, making it particularly suitable for enterprise-level organizations.

Procore's cloud-based architecture allows for seamless scaling of resources based on project demands. The platform handles multiple concurrent users efficiently and provides consistent performance across various devices and locations.

Selecting Your Construction Management Solution

Choosing between ProjectWise and Procore requires careful consideration of your organization's specific requirements and future growth plans. The decision impacts not only current project management capabilities but also long-term operational efficiency and team productivity.

Consider evaluating both platforms through trial periods and involving key team members in the assessment process. Pay particular attention to user adoption rates, integration capabilities with existing systems, and the total cost of ownership, including implementation and training expenses.

The success of either platform largely depends on proper implementation and team engagement. Organizations should develop a comprehensive adoption strategy, including thorough training programs and clear communication channels for support and feedback.

Sources: [1] https://www.procore.com/pricing [2] https://www.procore.com [3] https://buildops.com/commercial-construction/projectwise-software/ [4] https://www.jibble.io/construction-software-reviews/procore [5] https://www.bentley.com/software/projectwise/ [6] https://www.procore.com/jobsite/understanding-procores-pricing-model [7] https://6sense.com/tech/project-collaboration/procore-vs-bentleyprojectwise [8] https://www.trustradius.com/products/bentley-projectwise/reviews [9] https://www.procore.com/project-management [10] https://www.goodfirms.co/software/projectwise [11] https://www.trustradius.com/products/bentley-projectwise/reviews?qs=pros-and-cons [12] https://www.gti.com.hk/en/Solutions/Software-Applications/ProjectWise